When I see a box on the shelf at a friend’s I wonder, “How could they? Homemade are so much better!” And when the same friend sees me make my homemade version, they ask, “How could you? The box is so much easier!” If you do make your own croutons, then I’m preaching to the choir. If not, I implore you to try, just once. It’s really so so easy, and they are soooooo good. Especially if you start with a good quality Italian or French loaf bread, or a lovely baguette.
Easy Croutons on the Stovetop
Looking around at other recipes I’ve noticed that many people make croutons in the oven. I’ve done that (and still do on occasion); but you do have to be careful if you cook them that way. In the oven it’s easy to overcook them, turning them solid brown all around, when what you want it just lightly toasted on the outside, crunchy, but still a little spring in the bread. The way my mother makes croutons (once at year at least for her famed and fabulous turkey stuffing) is to toast them in a little melted butter in a wide shallow pan on the stove-top.
Tips for the Best Croutons
It’s best to use day old French or Italian loaf bread, but you can dry out the cubed bread in a warm oven for a few minutes if you are working with fresh bread.Butter is for the flavor. It can’t be beat. You don’t need anything else actually. Just butter. If you are working with butter and some good bread, the flavor is just perfect.
How to Make Seasoned Croutons
If you’d like to give your croutons some flavor, toss them with dried herbs or spices once they’re toasted and before removing the pan from heat. You don’t need much seasoning; a half teaspoon or so will do. Here are a few ideas for seasonings:
Ranch seasoning: black pepper, dried parsley, dried dill, and if you have it, powdered buttermilkItalian seasoning: dried basil, dried oregano, dried rosemary, and dried thymeSmoky seasoning: smoked paprika or smoked saltCurried croutons: curry powder or garam masalaGarlic croutons: mince a clove of garlic and sauté until fragrant in the melted butter before adding the croutons
Storing and Freezing Croutons
While these croutons are best when freshly made and still a little warm from the skillet, you can also cool them completely and store them in an airtight container for a few days on the counter or for up to a month in the freezer. You can also cut leftover bread into cubes and freeze it for making croutons or breadcrumbs.
Ways to Use Croutons
Use these croutons to top a soup or salad, or for making stuffing. Here are some favorite recipes:
Easy Tomato Soup Cream of Mushroom Soup Butternut Squash Soup Arugula Salad with Beets and Goat Cheese Mixed Green Salad with Pecans, Goat Cheese, and Honey Mustard Vinaigrette
If the bread cubes are not dry enough, spread them out on a baking sheet and put them in a warm oven (200°F or 90°C) for about 10 minutes. Then don’t stir them until they start to brown on one side. Once they start to brown, use a metal spatula to lift them up and turn them over, so more sides brown. When the croutons are at least a little toasted on a couple of sides, remove from heat. If storing, let cool completely before putting in an airtight container. Otherwise the steam released from the warm croutons will take away their crunch.
