These Molasses Cookies are very near and dear to my heart – mostly because they remind me of my dear mother-in-law. “Grandma Blick”, as we lovingly called her, made these cookies often. Grandma Blick always had a secret stash of these cookies in a tin hiding in a cupboard. She would pull them out and share them with everyone who came to visit. Now they’re one of my most treasured, favorite cookie recipes and I also love making them for my family. The soft, chewy cookie reminds me of a gingersnap, with a light molasses flavor and also sweetened by a sugary outside. If you’re looking for a warm, nostalgic cookie recipe, then this one is it!
Ingredients in Molasses Cookies
These cookies come together with simple pantry ingredients. They’re so easy to make! Here’s what you need:
Shortening – I find that using shortening instead of butter helps keep the cookies nice and soft.Egg – Just one egg. This recipe is easy to double!Molasses – I use light molasses instead of a super dark variety. More on what molasses to use down below.Flour – make sure to sift the dry ingredients together with the flour before adding to the molasses mixture.Baking soda – two teaspoons¼ teaspoon salt A half teaspoon ground clovesOne teaspoon ground cinnamonOne teaspoon ground ginger
What Type of Molasses to Use
A commenter asked what type of molasses to use. We prefer light molasses in this recipe. Light molasses tastes the sweetest and is most commonly used in baking. Dark molasses is a little less sweet, and is mostly used in gingerbread cookies. Blackstrap molasses is the thickest and most also most bitter type of molasses. We would advise you not to use that type of molasses in this recipe as it will not taste as good or have the right texture.
Recipe Tips
Chill the cookie dough for an hour before shaping into balls. Sprinkle water on top of the cookies. It will dissolve some of the sugar on top and give the cookies a nice, crinkly texture on top.The spices blend so well in the molasses, and the flavors mix together after sitting for a while. I like to store them for about a day before serving, because they just taste better the second day!Don’t overbake these cookies! To achieve the chewy texture, pull the cookies out of the oven when they are just starting to turn a light brown on top and you can see them getting crusty on the top layer of the cookie. Allow the cookies to cool completely on a wire rack before storing.If you want a super easy cleanup, then place a sheet of parchment paper on the baking sheet!
What Readers Are Saying About these Molasses Cookies
“Boy, I haven’t seen a molasses cookie recipe ever. My grandmother made these for me as a child and I thought they were just the best cookie ever. Thank you for sharing this one, it brings back the good old days… Smile.” – RHONDA “These were the best cookies I’ve ever had!” – CHUCK “These look so soft and chewy, I can’t wait to try them!” -SUSAN
Frequently Asked Questions About Molasses Cookies
Read More: 25+ Christmas Desserts
More Homemade Cookie Recipes
From classic chocolate chip to peanut butter, we have SO many delicious cookie recipes to choose from. Try some new cookie recipes with your family!
Bakery Chocolate Chip CookiesNo Bake CookiesGingerbread CookiesPeanut Butter CookiesSugar Cookies
Elf Cookies
Peanut Butter Cookies
Chewy Pecan Cookies
Gingerbread Cookies
Share It on Instagram!
